DATE: 15 June 2023
TO:
Mr Daniel Esdras, Minister of Migration and Asylum;
Mr Emmanuel Logothetis, Special Secretary-General for the Reception of Asylum Seekers;
Ms Patrina Paparrigopoulou, Minister of Labour and Social Affairs;
Ms Ylva Johansson, EU Commissioner for Home Affairs;
Ms Beate Gminder, Deputy Director-General of the European Commission (Task Force Migration Management).
CC:
Mr Michael Fakhri, UN Special Rapporteur on the right to food;
Mr Felipe González Morales, UN Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants.
On the 17th of May, Greek authorities announced that starting the next day food and water would no longer be provided for people outside of the asylum procedure living in the Lesvos Closed Controlled Access Centre (C.C.A.C.). Approximately 300 people staying in the C.C.A.C. are considered to be outside of the asylum procedure (excluding 200 similarly-situated children). Without warning or proper planning, these people are at immediate risk of food insecurity.
The Greek Ministry of Migration and Asylum maintains that under asylum and migration law only people applying for international protection are eligible for material reception conditions, including food and water.1 As nongovernmental (human rights) organisations working with people on the move, we want to emphasise that human dignity, and access to food and water, irrespective of legal status, are fundamental human rights. Greek authorities still have an obligation to facilitate access to food and water especially when people are unable to access it themselves.2
Recognised refugees – The vast majority of those in the C.C.A.C. who have been granted international protection have no way to sustain themselves outside the centre. Recognised refugees are cut off from cash assistance immediately after they are granted international protection, and according to legislation have to leave reception centres within 30 days.3
Recognised refugees, in theory, should receive support to integrate into the community and have access to certain social benefits. In practice, bureaucratic obstacles, such as lack of access to residence permits, travel documents, and temporary social security numbers, make access to support extremely difficult – especially within a 30-day window.4
1Hellenic Republic Law 4674/2020 Article 111; Hellenic Ministry of Migration and Asylum ‘All asylum seekers are eligible to feeding programmes in the camps since the 1st of October and they will also be granted financial aid at the end of the month’ (18 October 2021) <bit.ly/3P6RaRd>.
2 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (16 December 1966) Article 11; Committee on Economic, Social
and Cultural Rights (CESCR), General Comment 12 (12 May 1999) UN Doc E/C.12/1999/5; Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights ‘The Right to Adequate Food – factsheet no. 34’ (2010).
3 Hellenic Republic Law 4674/2020 Article 111.
4 European Commission Infringement Decision INFR(2022)2044; Intersos Hellas, Greek Forum of Migrants, Greek Council for
Refugees and Hias ‘Being Hungry in Europe: An analysis of the food insecurity experienced by refugees, asylum seekers, migrants 2/4
Rejected asylum seekers – Another category of people being denied provision of food and water are asylum seekers whose applications have received final rejections. This group includes those whose asylum applications were rejected, solely on admissibility grounds due to Greece’s consideration of Türkiye as a safe third country. Due to difficulties with returns and the fact that Türkiye has not accepted any readmissions since March 2020, these people are left in legal limbo, lacking access to legal status, rights, and basic services in Greece.
People with vulnerabilities and children – No exemptions have been communicated for people with vulnerabilities, including pregnant or lactating women, people with disabilities and older people, who may be more susceptible to rights violations. Some of these groups also should receive additional protection of their right to food under international human rights treaties and standards. Authorities have indicated that all children under 18, regardless of status, will continue to receive food but their adult caretakers will not. Moreover, children under 18 might still be denied food if they have been subjected to an incorrect age assessment.
Since the enforcement of these policies was announced, civil society groups have attempted to fill the gap left by Greek authorities by providing affected individuals with food and water. However, nongovernmental groups’ limited resources mean they can provide only a temporary solution. Moreover, Greek NGO legislation poses an additional obstacle to the provision of services by NGOs to people outside of the procedure especially those located at C.C.A.C’s.5
Unfortunately, this is not the first time large numbers of people face food insecurity. In October 2021, almost 60 percent of the residents of reception facilities on Greece’s mainland had lost access to sufficient food and water, causing severe distress and putting at-risk groups at even greater risk.6 Since then, civil society organisations have repeatedly raised the alarm about food insecurity among refugees and asylum seekers in mainland Greece.7 Yet, once again, Greek authorities are leveraging food insecurity to force people to leave the C.C.A.C. and Lesvos.
By letter dated 7 December 2021, EU Commissioner for Home Affairs, Ylva Johannson flagged that the “EU Commission has repeatedly called upon the Greek authorities to ensure that all persons, particularly the vulnerable, receive basic means of subsistence, notably food [.]”8 In order to ensure human dignity and basic rights, including the right to food and water, 42 organisations call on the Greek authorities and European Commission to immediately:
and undocumented people in Greece’ (2023) <bit.ly/45P4wHX>; Refugee Support Aegean ‘Systemic deficiencies in the access of
beneficiaries of international protection to documents and socio-economic rights’ (2023) <bit.ly/3qyMWHX>
5 Dunja Mijatović CoE Commissioner for Human Rights ‘letter to Mr Michalis CHRYSOCHOIDIS Minister for Citizens’ Protection of
Greece’ (3 May 2021) CommHR/DM/sf 019-2021; Expert Council on NGO Law NGO Law (Council of Europe) ‘Opinion on the
Compatibility With European Standards of Recent and Planned Amendments to Greek Legislation on NGO Registration’ (2 July 2020)
CONF/EXP(2020)4.
6 Joint open letter: Denying food – instead of receiving protection people go hungry on EU soil (Reliefweb, 27 October 2021)
<bit.ly/3WXKAOU>
7 NGOs Raise Alarm at Growing Hunger Amongst Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Greece (Refugees International, 29 November
2021) <bit.ly/3CmwGwq>; Helena Smith ‘Greek government blamed for hunger crisis in refugee camps’ (The Guardian, 24 January
2022) <bit.ly/43I4jo8>.
8 Observatory of the Refugee and Migration Crisis in the Aegean ‘EU Commissioner for Home Affairs, Ms. Ylva Johansson, issued a
robust response to a joint open letter by organisations working in Greece’ (2021) <bit.ly/3N1KyB5>.
3/4
- Ensure that everyone living in reception facilities, including the C.C.A.C. of Lesvos, have access to adequate food and water, independently and irrespective of their legal status until a careful assessment has been carried out to see if affected groups have sufficient means to guarantee subsistence and health.
- Guarantee that specific arrangements are in place to protect people with vulnerabilities and children outside of the asylum procedure from food insecurity.
- Reassess and extend the time recognised refugees are allowed to both stay inside
reception facilities, including C.C.A.C.s, and to access material reception conditions so they have reasonable time to access integration support, find adequate housing and
employment and increase the chances of self-sufficiency. - Recognise that food insecurity is directly connected to housing insecurity, inability to access social support and ineffective integration support.
Signed by:
1. Ariadni Lesvos
2. Better Days Greece
3. Boat Refugee Foundation
4. Border Violence Monitoring Network
5. Borderline Lesvos
6. Changemakers Lab
7. Choose Love
8. Coexistence & Communication in the Aegean – Συνύπαρξη & Επικοινωνία στο
Αιγαίο 9. Defence for Children International Greece
10. Doctors Without Borders – Greek Section – Γιατροί χωρίς Σύνορα – Ελληνικό
Τμήμα
11. Drapen I Havet – Σταγόνα
12. Dutch Council for Refugees
13. Equal Rights Beyond Borders
14. Europe Cares
15. Fenix Humanitarian Legal Aid
16. Germany Must Act
17. Greek Council for Refugees (GCR)
18. Greek Forum of Migrants
19. HIAS Greece
20. Hoffnung leben
21. Human Rights Watch
22. I Have Rights
23. Inter Alia
24. Just Action
25. Lean on us e.V.
26. Legal Centre Lesvos
27. Lesol
28. Lesvos Solidarity
29. Lighthouse Relief
30. Makerspace Lesvos
31. Medical Volunteers International e.V.
32. Mobile Info Team
4/4
33. Network for Children’s Rights
34. Project Armonia
35. ReFOCUS Media Labs
36. Refugee Legal Support
37. Refugee Support Aegean (RSA)
38. Starfish Foundation
39. Stichting Vluchteling
40. Symbiosis – Council of Europe School of Political Studies in Greece
41. Yoga and Sport with Refugees
42. #LeaveNoOneBehind
**photo by Julie Ricard for Unsplash
